• Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer
Equalize Digital Home

Equalize Digital

Website Accessibility Consulting, Training, and Development

  • My Account
  • Swag Shop
  • Checkout
  • Services
    • Accessibility Audits
    • User Testing
    • Accessibility Remediation
    • VPAT & ACR Preparation
    • Accessibility Monitoring
    • Web Accessibility Training
    • Accessibility for Agencies
  • Accessibility Checker
    • Overview
    • Features
    • Pricing
    • Documentation
    • Support
    • Buy Now
  • Company
    • About Us
    • Our Team
    • Industry Expertise
    • Accessibility Statement
    • Contact Sales
    • Become An Affiliate
  • Learn
    • Online Courses
    • Accessibility Meetup
    • Articles & Resources
    • Accessibility Craft Podcast
    • Upcoming Events
    • Office Hours
    • Custom Accessibility Training
    • Global Accessibility Awareness Day
  • Contact Sales
  • My Account
  • Checkout
Home / Learning Center / Settlement in Voting Rights Case Requires County Voting Website Accessibility

Settlement in Voting Rights Case Requires County Voting Website Accessibility

Article PublishedNovember 20, 2018Last UpdatedOctober 4, 2024 Written byEqualize Digital

people placing ballots in ballot boxes
Article Summary

In 2012, an accessible voting machine in California broke down. Because of this, 5 visually impaired people could not vote. The 5 voters and members of the California Council for the Blind sued the county. The Council said that the broken machine violated the ADA. It also violated a 2006 law that requires accessible voting tools. Now, in 2018, the case has been settled. The county has agreed to implement WCAG 2.1 as their accessibility standard. This was a big success for accessible voting. This is because it provides a new standard for other counties to follow. It may even become the standard across the country.

When participating in an election, whether local or federal, you may not think twice about your ability to cast your vote privately. But for 5 visually impaired voters in Alameda County, their right to privacy was taken away thanks to broken voting equipment. Now, after years of negotiations and discussion about voting website accessibility, the 5 voters, along with members of the California Council for the Blind, have reached a settlement with Alameda County.

Article continued below.

Stay on top of web accessibility news and best practices.

Join our email list to get notified of changes to website accessibility laws, WordPress accessibility resources, and accessibility webinar invitations in your inbox.

Name
Subscribe Consent(Required)
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Lawsuit Overview

This case came about when accessible voting equipment in Alameda County broke down and was unable to be repaired in 2012. Visually impaired voters were unable to cast their ballots without the assistance of a family member or poll worker. The 5 voters, along with Jeff Thom, President of the California Council for the Blind, filed a suit against the county under two different laws:

  1. A 2006 federal law that requires at least one machine with voting options and ballot instructions on headphones and tactile keyboards at each polling location.
  2. The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), which entitles individuals with disabilities equal access to government activities, programs, and services.

Alameda County argued that the ADA only guaranteed equal access to voting, and it did not apply to private ballots and vote casting. And while federal courts had agreed with Alameda County in past cases, U.S. Magistrate Joseph Spero from San Francisco did not. Spero argued that a secret ballot is a central feature of voting, and casting a vote with the assistance of a third party is an inferior voting experience.

Settlement Terms

Alameda County chose not to appeal the ruling from Spero, and the two parties were able to reach an agreement using structured negotiation. The agreement, which was reached on November 2, 2018, is the first in the country to implement WCAG 2.1 as the accessibility standard. It states that Alameda County will:

  • Purchase accessible voting machines
  • Improve poll worker training
  • Set up an election day hotline for repairing or replacing broken equipment
  • Implement an accessible vote by mail system
  • Conduct automated and manual web accessibility testing
  • Establish a user accessibility testing group
  • Hold up to WCAG 2.1 standards

Additionally, the county’s voting website will allow certain content, such as sample ballots and voter information pamphlets to be accessed in accordance with WCAG 2.1. The Disability Rights Advocates group was awarded $70,000 to monitor the county’s accessible voting performance for the next three years.

What This Means for Voting Website Accessibility

This settlement is not just a simple “win,” but a huge step forward for voting website accessibility. The decision made by Alameda County to provide a more accessible voting process may even set a precedent for the rest of the country to follow. It also ensures that the rights of visually impaired voters (at least) in this county will be protected and upheld.

Facebook0Tweet0LinkedIn0Print0Shares0

Filed Under: Web Accessibility Laws & Court Cases Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Blind/Visual Impairments Government Agencies Situational Limitations

About Equalize Digital

Equalize Digital's team has specialized in WordPress accessibility for more than a decade. We offer accessibility audits, WordPress accessibility remediation, user testing, and build bespoke, accessibility-first websites. Our WordPress Accessibility Checker plugin is used by large and small businesses, nonprofits, higher ed, and government websites worldwide. Try it free today.

Post navigation

man looking at website on laptop computerPrevious post: U.S. Department of Justice Affirms That the ADA Applies to Websites
birthday cakeNext post: Happy Birthday, WCAG! W3C Web Content Accessibility Guidelines are 20 Years Old This Week

Easier, Faster Accessibility Testing

Equalize Digital Accessibility Checker gives you real-time accessibility feedback in the WordPress editor. Learn accessibility and make fixes earlier in the dev and content creation process. Full-site accessibility scanning without the per page fees.

Get Accessibility Checker

Footer

Equalize Digital Websites for Everyone

Your WordPress accessibility team. Accessibility plugins, rapid audits, and consulting to help you make your website usable by people of all abilities.

  • Facebook
  • GitHub
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Company

  • About Equalize Digital
  • WordPress Accessibility Meetup
  • Accessibility Statement
  • Blog
  • Events
  • Contact Us

Services

  • Accessibility Audits
  • User Testing
  • Remediation
  • Ongoing Monitoring
  • VPAT & ACR Preparation
  • Accessibility Training
  • For Agencies
  • Website Development

Accessibility Checker

  • Features
  • Pricing
  • Documentation
  • How to Get Support
  • My Account
  • Affiliate Dashboard
  • Become an Affiliate

© 2025 Equalize Digital · Privacy Policy · Terms of Service · Software Terms & Refund Policy

International Association of Accessibility Professionals member